4.5 Arguments (Short Notes)

4.5 Arguments

(A) Premises and Conclusions
1. An argument is a process of making conclusion based on several given statements.
2. The statements given are known as premises.
3. An argument consists of premises and a conclusion.

Example 1:

Identify the premises and conclusion of the following argument.
(a) A pentagon has 5 sides. ABCDE is a pentagon. Therefore, ABCDE has 5 sides.

Solution:
Premise 1: A pentagon has 5 sides.
Premise 2: ABCDE is a pentagon.
Conclusion: ABCDE has 5 sides.


(B) Forms of Arguments
1. Based on two given premises, a conclusion can be made for three different forms of arguments.

Argument Form I
Premise 1: All A are B.
Premise 2: C is A.
Conclusion: C is B.
Example 2:
Make a conclusion based on the two premises given below.
Premise 1: All multiples of 5 are divisible by 5.
Premise 2: 45 is a multiple of 5.
Conclusion: ______________

Solution:
Conclusion: 45 is divisible by 5.

Argument Form II
Premise 1: If p, then q.
Premise 2: p is true.
Conclusion: q is true.
Example 3:
Make a conclusion based on the two premises given below.
Premise 1: If a number is a factor of 18, then the number is a factor of 54.
Premise 2: 3 is a factor of 18.
Conclusion: ______________

Solution:
Conclusion: 3 is a factor of 54.

Argument Form III
Premise 1: If p, then q.
Premise 2: Not q is true.
Conclusion: Not p is true.

Example 4:
Make a conclusion based on the two premises given below.
Premise 1: If P is a subset of Q, then P  Q = P.
Premise 2P  Q  P
Conclusion: ______________

Solution:
Conclusion: P is not the subset of Q.

4.4 Implication

(A) Antecedent and Consequent of an Implication

  1. For two statements p and q, the sentence ‘if p, then q’ is called an implication.
  2. p is called the antecedent.
    q is called the consequent.


Example:

Identify the antecedent and consequent of the following implications.

(a) If m = 2, then 2m2 + m = 10

(b) I f P Q = P , t h e n Q P

Solution:

  1. Antecedent: m = 2
    Consequent: 2m2 + m = 10
  2. Antecedent : P Q = P Consequent : Q P

(B) Implications of the Form ‘p if and only if q

  1. Two implications ‘if p, then q and ‘if q, then p can be written as ‘p if and only if q.
  2. Likewise, two statements can be written from a statement in the form ‘p if and only if q as follows:
    Implication 1: If p, then q.
    Implication 2: If q, then p.


Example 1:

Given that p: x + 1 = 8
q: x = 7
Construct a mathematical statement in the form of implication

  1. If p, then q.
  2. p if and only if q.

Solution:

  1. If x + 1 = 8, then x = 7.
  2. x + 1 = 8 if and only if x = 7.

Example 2:

Write down two implications based on the following sentence:
x3 = 64 if and only if x = 4.

Solution:

If x3 = 64, then x = 4.
If x = 4, then x3 = 64.

(C) Converse of an Implication

  1. The converse of an implication ‘if p, then q’ is if q, then p’.

Example:

State the converse of each of the following implications.

  1. If x2 + x – 2 = 0, then (x – 1)(x + 2) = 0.
  2. If x = 7, then x + 2 = 9.

Solution:

  1. If (x – 1)(x + 2) = 0, then x2 + x – 2.
  2. If x + 2 = 9, then x = 7.

 

 

4.6 SPM Practice (Long Questions)


Question 7:
(a)(i) State whether the following compound statement is true or false.

3 + 3 = 9 or   3 × 3 = 9
(a)(ii) Determine whether the following converse is true or false.

If x > 3, then x > 7
(b) Write down Premise 2 to complete the following argument:
Premise 1: If y = mx + 5 is a linear equation, then m is a gradient of the straight line.
Premise 2: _____________________
Conclusion: 2 is the gradient of the straight line.

(c) Angle subtended at the centre of a regular polygon with n sides is 360 o n .
Make one conclusion by deduction for the angle subtended at the centre of a regular polygon with 5 sides.

Solution:
(a)(i) True

(a)(ii)
The converse is true

(b) Premise 2: y = 2x + 5 is a linear equation

(c)
Angle subtended at the centre of a regular pentagon = 360 o n = 360 o 5 = 72 o


Question 8:
(a) State whether the following sentence is a statement or not a statement.

x + 7 = 9
(b) Complete the following compound statement by writing the word ‘or’ or ‘and’ to form a true statement.
23 = 6 …… 5 × 0 = 0

(c) Write down Premise 2 to complete the following argument:
Premise 1: All isosceles triangles have two equal sides.
Premise 2: _____________________
Conclusion: ABC has two equal sides.

(d) Make a general conclusion by induction for the sequence of numbers 1, 7, 17, 31, … which follows the following pattern.
1 = (2 × 1) – 1
7 = (2 × 4) – 1
17 = (2 × 9) – 1
31 = (2 × 16) – 1

Solution:
(a) Not a statement

(b) 23 = 6 …or… 5 × 0 = 0

(c) ABC is an isosceles triangle.

(d)
1 = (2 × 1) – 1 =  (2 × 12) – 1
7 = (2 × 4) – 1 =  (2 × 22) – 1
17 = (2 × 9) – 1 =  (2 × 32) – 1
31 = (2 × 16) – 1 =  (2 × 42) – 1
  =  2n2 – 1, n = 1, 2, 3, …

4.5 Arguments

(A) Premises and Conclusions

  1. An argument is a process of making conclusion based on several given statements.
  2. The statements given are known as premises.
  3. An argument consists of premises and a conclusion.

Example 1:

Identify the premises and conclusion of the following argument.

  1. A pentagon has 5 sides. ABCDE is a pentagon. Therefore, ABCDE has 5 sides.

Solution:

Premise 1: A pentagon has 5 sides.
Premise 2: ABCDE is a pentagon.
Conclusion: ABCDE has 5 sides.

(B) Forms of Arguments

  1. Based on two given premises, a conclusion can be made for three different forms of arguments.

Argument Form I

Premise 1: All A are B.
Premise 2: C is A.
Conclusion: C is B.

Example 2:

Make a conclusion based on the two premises given below.

Premise 1: All multiples of 5 are divisible by 5.
Premise 2: 45 is a multiple of 5.
Conclusion:  _______________

Solution:

Conclusion: 45 is divisible by 5.

Argument Form II

Premise 1: If p, then q.
Premise 2: p is true.
Conclusion: q is true.

Example 3:

Make a conclusion based on the two premises given below.
Premise 1: If a number is a factor of 18, then the number is a factor of 54.
Premise 2: 3 is a factor of 18.
Conclusion:  _______________

Solution:

Conclusion: 3 is a factor of 54.

Argument Form III

Premise 1: If p, then q.
Premise 2: Not q is true.
Conclusion: Not p is true.

Example 4:

Make a conclusion based on the two premises given below.
Premise 1: If P is a subset of Q, then PQ = P .
Premise 2: PQP
Conclusion:  _______________

Solution:

Conclusion: P is not the subset of Q.

 

 

4.6 SPM Practice (Long Questions)

Question 5:
(a) State if each of the following statements is true or false.
 (i)    23= 8 or ⅓ = 1.33.
 (ii)  – 6 > – 8 and 6 > 8.
 
(b) Write down two implications based on the following statement:

x a + y b =1 if and only if bx+ay=ab.

(c) It is given that the interior angle of a regular polygon of n sides 
  is   ( 1 2 n ) × 180 .
  Make one conclusion by deduction on the size of the interior angle of a regular hexagon.

Solution:

(a)(i) True

(a)(ii) False

(b) 

Implication 1:   If   x a + y b =1, then bx+ay=ab. _ Implication 2:   If  bx+ay=ab, then  x a + y b =1. _

(c)
Size of an interior angle of a regular hexagon = ( 1 2 6 ) × 180 = 2 3 × 180 = 120


Question 6:
(a) Complete the following mathematical sentence by writing the symbol > or <.
  (i) 53____ 20 is a false statement.
  (ii) – 3 ____ – 10 is a true statement.

(b) Complete the conclusion in the following argument:
 Premise 1 : If  n 1 2 = n , then  4 1 2 = 4 =2.   Premise 2 :  n 1 2 = n  Conclusion : _____________________
(c) Make a general conclusion by induction for the sequence of numbers 10, 35, 70, … which follows the following pattern.

10 = 5 (2)2 – 10 
35 = 5 (3)2 – 10
70 = 5 (4)2 – 10
…. = ………..

Solution:
(a)(i) 53   <    20 is a false statement.

(a)(ii)   – 3    >    – 10 is a true statement.

(b)

Conclusion : 4 1 2 = 4 = 2

(c) 5 (n + 1)2 – 10, where n = 1, 2, 3, …


4.4 Implications Short Notes

4.4 Implications

(A) Antecedent and Consequent of an Implication
1. For two statements p and q, the sentence ‘if p, then q’ is called an implication.

2. p is called the antecedent.
   q is called the consequent.

Example:
Identify the antecedent and consequent of the following implications.
(a) If m = 2, then 2m2 + m = 10
(b) If PQ=P, then QP

Solution:
(a) Antecedent: m = 2
Consequent:2m2 + m = 10

(b) Antecedent:PQ=P       Consequent:QP


(B) Implications of the Form ‘p if and only if q
1. Two implications ‘if p, then q’ and ‘if q, then p’ can be written as ‘p if and only if q’.
2. Likewise, two statements can be written from a statement in the form p if and only if q as follows:
Implication 1: If p, then q.
Implication 2: If q, then p.

Example 1:
Given that p: x + 1 = 8
 q: x = 7
Construct a mathematical statement in the form of implication
(a) If p, then q.
(b) p if and only if q.

Solution:
(a) If x + 1 = 8, then x = 7.
(b) x + 1 = 8 if and only if x = 7. 

Example 2:
Write down two implications based on the following sentence:
x3 = 64 if and only if x = 4.

Solution:
If x3 = 64, then x = 4.
If x = 4, then x3 = 64.



(C) Converse of an Implication
1. The converse of an implication ‘if p, then q’ is ‘if q, then p’.
 
Example:
State the converse of each of the following implications.
(a) If x2 + x – 2 = 0, then (x - 1)(x + 2) = 0.
(b) If x = 7, then x + 2 = 9.

Solution:
(a) If (x - 1)(x + 2) = 0, then x2 + x – 2.
(b) If x + 2 = 9, then x = 7.

4.1 Statements

(A) Determine Whether a Given Sentence is a Statement
1. A statement is a sentence which is either true or false but not both.

2. Sentences which are questions, instructions and exclamations are not statements.

Example 1:
Determine whether the following sentences are statements or not. Give a reason for your answer.
(a) 3 + 3 = 8
(b) A pentagon has 5 sides.
(c) Is 40 divisible by 3?
(d) Find the perimeter of a square with each side of 4 cm.
(e) Help!

Solution:
(a) Statement; it is a false statement.
(b) Statement; it is a true statement.
(c) Not a statement; it is a question.
(d) Not a statement; it is an instruction.
(e) Not a statement; it is an exclamation.



(B) Determine Whether a Statement is True or False.

Example 2:
Determine whether each of the following statements is true or false.
(a) 7 is a prime number
(b) -10 > -7
(c) 3 is a factor of 8.

Solution:
(a) True
(b) False
(c) False



(C) Constructing Statements Using Numbers and Symbols
 
1. True and false statements can be constructed with numbers and mathematical symbols.
 
Example 3:
Construct (i) a true statement, (ii) a false statement,
using the following numbers and mathematical symbols.
(a) 2, 4, 8, ×, =
(b) {a, b, c}, {d} , U =

Solution:
(a)(i) A true statement: 2 × 4 = 8
(a)(ii) A false statement: 2 × 8 = 4
(b)(i) A true statement: {d} U {a, b, c} = {a, b, c, d}
(b)(ii) A false statement: {d} U {a, b, c} = {d}



4.2 Quantifiers ‘All’ and ‘Some’

4.2 Quantifiers ‘All’ and ‘Some’
 
Statement using ‘All’ and ‘Some’
1. Quantifiers are words that denote the number of objects or cases referred to in a given statement.
2. Quantifier ‘all’, ‘any’ and ‘every’ describe each and every object or case.
3. Quantifier ‘some’, ‘several’ and ‘part of’ describe one or more objects or cases.
 
Example:
Complete each of the following statements using the quantifiers ‘all’ or ‘some’ to make the statement true.
(a) _______  polygons have the same number of vertices and sides.
(b) _______  multiples of 9 are even numbers.
(c) _______  of the whole numbers are divisible by 7.
(d) _______  factors of 4 are factors of 20.
 
Solution:
(a) All polygons have the same number of vertices and sides.
(b) Some multiples of 9 are even numbers.
(c) Some of the whole numbers are divisible by 7.
(d) All factors of 4 are factors of 20.

4.3 Operations on Statements

4.3 Operations on Statements (Part 1)
 
(A) Nagating a Statement using ‘No’ or ‘Not’
 
1. Negation of a statement refers to changing the truth value of the statement, that is, changing a true statement to a false statement and vice versa, using the word ‘not’ or ‘no’.
 
Example 1:
Change the true value of the following statements by using ‘no’ or ‘not’.
(a) 17 is a prime number.
(b) 39 is a multiple of 9.
 
Solution:
(a) 17 is not a prime number. (True to false)
(b) 39 not is a multiple of 9. (False to true)


2. A compound statement can be formed by combining two given statements using the word ‘and’.
 
Example 2:
Identify two statements from each of the following compound statements.
(a) All pentagons have 5 sides and 5 vertices.
(b) 33 = 27 and 43 = 64
 
Solution:
(a) All pentagons have 5 sides.
 All pentagons have 5 vertices.
(b) 33 = 27
  43 = 64



Example 3:
Form a compound statement from each of the following pairs of statements using the word ‘and’.
(a) 19 is a prime number.
  19 is an odd number.
(b) 15 – 5 = 10
  15 × 5 = 75

Solution:
(a) 19 is a prime number and an odd number. ← (Repeated words can be eliminated when combining two statements using ‘and’.)

(b) 15 – 5 = 10 and15 × 5 = 75.


3. A compound statement can also be formed by combining two given statements using the word ‘or’.
 
Example 4:
Form a compound statement from each of the following pairs of statements using the word ‘or’.
(a) 11 is an odd number.
  11 is a prime number.
(b) 3 = 27 3 3 = 4 + 1

Solution:
(a) 11 is an odd number or a prime number.
( b) 3 = 27 3 or 3 = 4 + 1

3.4 SPM Practice (Long Questions)


Question 3:
(a) The Venn diagrams in the answer space shows sets P and Q such that the universal set, ξ = P υ Q.
  Shade the set PQ.
(b) The Venn diagrams in the answer space shows sets X and Y and Z, such that the universal set, ξ = X υ Y υ Z.
  Shade the set (υ Z) ∩ Y.

Solution:

(a)

PQ means the intersection of the region P and the region Q.

(b)


• (X υ Z) means the union of the region X and the region Z.
• The region then intersects with region Y to give the result (X υ Z) ∩ Y.





Question 4:
The Venn diagrams in the answer space shows sets P, Q and R such that the universal set, ξ = P υ Q υ R
On the diagrams in the answer space, shade
(a) PR’,
(b) P’υ (QR).

Solution:
(a)
P ∩ R
(b)
P’υ (Q ∩ R)